Extra, Extra, Read All About It! On Second Thought, Don’t. Please Don’t.

Hi readers,

I try not to repeat topics on this blog but sometimes I feel we need a refresher course. Today is one such time.

It happened again. It’s been a few weeks, but I kind of had to let it simmer before writing about it. Otherwise I might have exploded.

Our local news station does a segment called Person of the Week. It may be similar to one in your city or town, where the local media honors a person who gives back to others in a big way. It may be the lady who started a halfway house for addicts. It might be the guy who rescues kittens and puppies slated for euthanasia in shelters, and sees they get adopted. It might be the coach or teacher who’s been at X school for like, 20 years and influenced hundreds of students in a positive way. You know these people and the world is better because of them.

Our Person of the Week that week was a baseball coach. Great. He’s been coaching for awhile and from what I saw is darn good at it. Wonderful. He’s also described as especially compassionate. And as the newscaster expressed that, a brief shot of a player with Down Syndrome was shown.

Tweet! Flag on the play! I know, football, not baseball, but I hate sports so whatever.

I love that this coach is compassionate toward students with disabilities. I love that a student with Down Syndrome was featured in the newscast. But the way it was presented, purposely or not, I continually find exploitive in the media.

This isn’t the first time I’ve seen it happen either. May is prom season, and so a lot of girls get “prom-posals” (I feel those are ridiculous but that’s neither here nor there). May is also the season that some girls invite guys with disabilities to the prom–or guys invite girls. And because one half of that couple has a disability, the event gets written up in the paper. It’s like they’re saying, “Gasp! A disabled person is doing something normal! Someone actually had the guts and compassion to include them! Extra, extra, read all about it!”

Not to be crass here, but…gag me with a shovel.

I’m sorry. I know it’s probably a huge deal to families, friends, teachers, and whoever when a student with a disability gets invited to prom. I know being written up is an honor. I know it makes everybody feel warm and fuzzy inside, and I hope everyone has a great time at those proms. But please, please, for the love of all that is holy, stop writing people with disabilities up in the newspaper for doing what the majority of the population does every day of our lives.

I’ve said this to a lot of people, including those closest to me. Some, especially those closest to me, think I’m being mean and unfair, so I shut up. But this is a blog. Outside of my alias you don’t know me (except if you email me directly, in which case you know my real first name). So I feel safe here telling the truth which is, the people who exploit PWDs, through feel-good stories or otherwise, are the ones being mean.

Think about it, folks. I mean really, think. If you’ve got a kid or teenager at home, how would you feel if the local news crew surrounded your kid’s coach and snapped his or her picture and said, “You’re so compassionate for letting Tommy play after he lost a tooth”? If they said something like, “Despite being of mixed race/having a freckle on her nose/being the only Muslim in school, Serena was given a prom-posal?”


You would be absolutely SHRIEKING. You. Would. Sue. You would probably want to find the reporter responsible and shove the microphone up their butt.

So why–why oh, why–do we continually do the same thing to people with disabilities? I’m not talking about newsworthy stuff, like if a person with Down Syndrome competed in the Winter Olympic games and won gold, or if a person with cerebral palsy raised $10,000 for charity with her own tutoring business. I’m talking about using another person because you want to feel good. I’m talking about sending a message that says, “You are so far from normal, there is so little hope for you, that anything you do ‘like us’ is this amazing thing. You can have your 15 minutes of fame, but only the way we want you to have it.” It sends the overall message that at the end of the day, temporarily able-bodied people are better than PWDs. After all, they make the rules. They decide what’s newsworthy. They decide what PWDs can and can’t do.

I’m tired of letting them decide. I say it’s time for us to decide. And the first thing we need to decide is how we treat persons with disabilities. Do we continue the exploitation? Or do we give them authentic, meaningful praise in the privacy of our own circles, give them real inclusion opportunities, and make everybody feel good?

A PWD who lives a life of their choosing, who isn’t necessarily newsworthy all the time but has friends and family and a life he or she enjoys? That might be worth a report. But to all these other feel-good stories? I say, please get out of my newspaper.



  1. Whenever I see these prom/homecoming news stories a few things I always wonder is: What happens after the big dance is over and the news crews leave the high school, are the other students going to be hanging out with the HKWD (homecoming king with disabilities) after homecoming season is over or will they continue to exclude him like they did before?

  2. I always notice with those Prom-posals, it’s a TAB person inviting a person with a disability to the prom that gets the attention. Never a pair of people with down syndrome. Never a couple in wheelchairs. No, it’s always “look, this able bodied person is so awesome and amazing that they actually stooped to inviting a disabled person! Aren’t they heroic?” Gag me with a shovel, indeed. I think that able-bodied and disabled people should be free to date or do things together, but when the story is always framed as heroic able bodied person showing compassion to the lesser disabled person it’s disgusting.

  3. Yeppers–one of the most disgusting things I have ever seen. And do you ever notice, it’s always pointed out that the TAB person is popular, like a cheerleader or the quarterback? Not even touching that one–it’s disgusting on a dysentery-infested mattress level.

  4. Yeah, they’re always gawking at how a person with a disability could EVER have even a CHANCE at EVER being asked to prom or being included in a baseball team, and they’re not even coming from the standpoint of “look at this refreshing break from an incredibly ableist society”, they’re thinking, “IT’S SO INSPIRATIONAL THAT ANYBODY WOULD EVER LET A DISABLED PERSON DO ANYTHING AT ALL, OMG, LOOK HOW CUTE, OMG, SUCH AN INSPIRATION THAT THE DISABLED PEOPLE EVEN LEAVE THEIR HOUSES RATHER THAN MOPE AROUND, OMG, THEY ACTUALLY INVITED THE DISABLED KID, AND DISABLED PEOPLE ARE BARELY PEOPLE, DID YOU KNOW THAT!?” That’s what they’re doing, and THEY KNOW IT!!!

    1. Indeed. Of course, they defend themselves by saying, “Oh, look how hard it is for disabled people” and, “I did NOT say OMG how cute.” But, even if you don’t say that, it’s what you mean. And don’t even try defending yourself, because doing so shows you are not interested in moving past ableism. SMH.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s